Skip to content
Cowlick's Creamery 521 Boston Post Rd Waterford, CT 06385
 

Christmas Pre-Order

Christmas Pies

  • Eggnog Pie - 9"

    Eggnog Pie - 9"

    Graham cracker or Gingersnap crust filled with eggnog ice cream, topped with whipped cream border and graham cracker crumbs.

    $25.00
  • Peppermint Stick Pie - 9"

    Peppermint Stick Pie - 9"

    Chocolate Graham crust filled with peppermint stick ice cream and topped with whipped cream border and chocolate sprinkles

    $25.00
  • Mud Pie - 9"

    Mud Pie - 9"

    Mud pie - Chocolate graham crust filled with cappuccino crunch ice cream and topped with whipped cream border and slivered almonds.

    $25.00
  • Peanut Butter Bomb Pie - 9"

    Peanut Butter Bomb Pie - 9"

    Our signature sundae made into a pie! Chocolate graham cracker crust filled with chocolate ice cream, chocolate sauce, peanut butter sauce and chopped peanut butter cups. Topped with our housemade peanut butter buttercream and Reese's Pieces.

    $25.00
  • Cookie Butter Pie - 9"

    Cookie Butter Pie - 9"

    Biscoff cookie crust filled with vanilla ice cream with a middle layer of cookie butter and crushed biscoff cookies, topped with whipped cream border, crushed biscoff cookies and cookie butter drizzle.

    $25.00